Leafs Nation Let's Pump the Breaks on the Goalie Debate

 


Photo From the Toronto Star

Apparently, Leafs Nation has already decided who the starting goaltender should be, and we're barely a month into the season. Are we really doing this again? The latest debate surrounding the Toronto Maple Leafs has shifted to the goaltending situation, and naturally, the media and armchair GMs are doing everything they can to turn it into a controversy.

Let's start with Anthony Stolarz. There's no denying he's had an excellent start to the season, posting a 5-1 record. That's great, and nobody is taking anything away from him. However, before everyone starts handing him the number one job, perhaps we should take a little trip down memory lane.

Do you remember how last season went for Stolarz? Apparently, some of you don't, so allow me to refresh your memories.

The Leafs got off to a disappointing start, and heading into the November 11th game against Boston, Stolarz publicly called out his teammates and told them they needed to play better. What happened next? He left the game with an injury, and Toronto went on to lose 5-3.

Things didn't exactly get better from there. Stolarz was asked to report to the Marlies for a few conditioning games, but he refused and wanted to start against Vegas when Mitch Marner returned to Toronto. I was in attendance that night, and let me tell you, it wasn't pretty. The Leafs got their asses kicked 6-3, and Stolarz was once again anything but impressive.

His season eventually ended with a 10-10-3 record. His final start came on April 2nd against San Jose, another 4-1 loss, and, wouldn't you know it, he left that game with yet another injury.

So, forgive me if I'm not ready to hand Anthony Stolarz the number one goaltending job after one good month. Yes, he's playing well, and I hope he continues to do so. But we're talking about a goalie who finished last season with a losing record and battled injuries throughout the year. Leafs fans need to stop looking at the most recent box score and start looking at the bigger picture.

Here's another question for those convinced Stolarz is Toronto's number one: If he's already the guy, why did the Leafs go out and sign Sergei Bobrovsky this summer?

I'll tell you why. Because the organization understands that it needs two capable goaltenders, especially when one of them has struggled to stay healthy. Stolarz's biggest problem has never been his ability to stop pucks. It's his ability to stay healthy. Until he proves he can handle the workload of a number one goaltender, I'm not ready to hand him that responsibility.

Now, let's talk about Bobrovsky.

Apparently, a difficult month of October is all it takes for some Leafs fans to completely write off a two-time Stanley Cup champion and three-time finalist. We're talking about a future first-ballot Hall of Famer, yet the armchair GMs who think they're hockey experts because they win games on PlayStation are already acting like Bobrovsky has forgotten how to stop a puck. Maybe it's time some of these so-called experts put down the controller and remembered that managing a hockey team in a video game and evaluating an NHL goaltender are two very different things.

Give me a break.

Bobrovsky has a career record of 72-36-11 in the month of November. He's accomplished more in this league than most goaltenders could ever dream of, and suddenly, we're supposed to believe he's finished because he hasn't looked spectacular through the first month of the season?

I'm not buying it.

Goaltending isn't always about what happened last night or what happened last week. It's about experience, consistency, and knowing what it takes to win when the pressure is at its highest. Bobrovsky has been there and done that. He's won two Stanley Cups and has been a finalist three times. Those accomplishments don't suddenly disappear because of a difficult stretch.

Sergei Bobrovsky will be fine. It's November, not April, and there's an awful lot of hockey left to play. Maybe we could give the guy a little time before throwing him under the bus.

And here's something else I can pretty much guarantee: When Bobrovsky starts putting together wins and reminding everyone why he's one of the best goaltenders of his generation, some of these same critics will either disappear into hiding or suddenly change their tune. They'll be the first ones claiming they always believed in him.

That's how it works in Leafs Nation. One good month makes you a superstar, and one bad month makes you expendable.

Maybe instead of jumping to conclusions, we could let the season play out. Stolarz deserves credit for his excellent start, and Bobrovsky deserves the opportunity to find his game. There's room for both goaltenders here, and Toronto is going to need both of them if this team hopes to accomplish anything meaningful.

Comments

Popular Posts