Leafs Let One Slip Away

 





Photo from the Toronto Maple Leafs

The Toronto Maple Leafs returned home from a three-game road trip that ended with a tough 5-4 loss in Utah, looking to get back in the win column against the Buffalo Sabres on Thursday night. After two periods, it looked like the Leafs were going to do exactly that. Auston Matthews found the back of the net, while Kirill Marchenko put on a show by scoring a hat trick. Toronto had a 4-2 lead late in the second period, and everything seemed to be going according to plan.

Then things fell apart.

Late in the second period, John Tavares went down with an injury, and while the Leafs managed to carry their two-goal lead into the intermission, whatever momentum they had built seemed to disappear when the third period began.

Instead of continuing to attack, Toronto appeared content to sit back and protect its lead. Now, I'm certainly no NHL coach, but I know enough about this team to understand that sitting back and defending a lead isn't exactly a recipe for success. You can get away with that approach when you have a reliable defensive group that can shut down the opposition. When you're the Maple Leafs, however, you need to keep pushing forward.

And, as we've seen far too many times, things can go sideways in a hurry.

Buffalo took advantage of Toronto's defensive breakdowns, clawed its way back into the game, and eventually forced overtime. That's where Owen Power delivered the final blow, scoring the game-winner to give the Sabres a 5-4 victory and leave the Leafs wondering how they managed to let this one slip away.

It's a frustrating loss, there's no question about that. But while the final score tells one story, another storyline was developing throughout the night, and it has plenty of Leafs fans asking questions.

For the entire game, Gavin McKenna played fewer than seven minutes. Yes, you read that correctly. Fewer than seven minutes!

Fans were understandably puzzled by the decision, and after the game, head coach Jim Hiller was asked to explain why one of Toronto's young players had barely seen the ice. Unfortunately, his explanation didn't exactly clear things up.

Here is what Hiller had to say:

"You know what? That was my decision. We went for a stretch. I think we had those penalties. I wanted to get him out there. He sat through the penalties, and then I didn't get him out there. You know, through that stretch, and then in the last few minutes of the period, we're just trying to, you know, get out of the period. I guess you would say. And then now, as I've sat him for so long, and he sits in the intermission, so I probably should have gotten him out there early in the third. I didn't. So I'll talk to him about that."

Jim, I have a question for you. If you want this kid to develop into the player you believe he can be, how exactly is he supposed to do that when he's sitting on the bench for most of the game?

I understand that McKenna is a rookie. I understand that there will be situations where he won't see the ice as much, particularly when the team is killing penalties. That's part of the game, and nobody expects a young player to be perfect.

But fewer than seven minutes? Come on!

McKenna is going to make mistakes. Every young player does. The important thing is how he learns from those mistakes, and that requires giving him opportunities to play. You cannot expect a rookie to gain experience and develop his game if you keep him glued to the bench.

Hiller admitted that he probably should have gotten McKenna back on the ice earlier in the third period. At least he acknowledged that much, but it still leaves me wondering why it took so long for him to recognize the situation in the first place.

I'm not calling for Hiller to be fired over one game. I've already seen fans online demanding that he be shown the door, and while I understand the frustration, I think we need to take a step back and look at the bigger picture.

We are eight games into the season, Leafs fans!

Toronto has a 3-3-2 record. Is that where we want the team to be? Of course not. Should we be concerned about some of the things we've seen? Absolutely. But does that mean the season is already falling apart? Not even close.

There is a long way to go, and this team has plenty of time to find its rhythm. We've already seen what this group can do when things are clicking, and I believe the Leafs will eventually get things moving in the right direction.

Will there be more frustrating losses along the way? You can count on it. This is Toronto, after all, and if there's one thing we've learned as Leafs fans, it's that this team can test your patience like few others.

But we cannot spend the entire season hitting the panic button every time something goes wrong.

For once, Leaf fans, let's take a deep breath and give this team a chance to figure things out. The 18-wheeler isn't driving off a cliff in the middle of October!

Yes, the loss to Buffalo was disappointing. The third-period collapse was frustrating, and Hiller needs to do a better job of managing his young players. We can acknowledge those issues without declaring the season a disaster.

The Leafs will now turn their attention to an early-season rematch against the New York Islanders, a team Toronto defeated 2-1 earlier this month.

We should receive an update on John Tavares's condition on Friday, and hopefully, the injury isn't serious. Tavares has gotten off to a strong start in the 2026-27 campaign, and the last thing the Leafs need is to lose him for an extended period.

I'll be keeping an eye on that situation, and hopefully, we'll have some good news heading into the weekend.

One other quick note for readers: there likely won't be a write-up following Saturday night's game, as I'll be in attendance as part of my birthday weekend. Sometimes, you have to put the keyboard aside and enjoy being a fan in person!

Losing a game like this is frustrating, especially when you have a two-goal lead heading into the third period. Nobody likes watching the Leafs give away a game they should have won, and there are certainly things this team needs to clean up.

But we're eight games into the season. There is plenty of hockey left to play, and I'm not ready to write off this team just yet.

Criticize the mistakes, question the decisions, and expect better. That's part of being a passionate Leafs fan. Just don't confuse a frustrating start with a lost season.

The 18-wheeler isn't driving off a cliff in October. Let's step away from the panic button, give this team time to find its groove, and remember that the season is far from over.

Comments

Popular Posts