Stop Looking At Vladdy Look at the Real Problem
I am probably wasting my time writing this, but I need to blow off some steam.
I am sick and tired of people telling me that I blindly defend Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Seriously?
If you have actually paid attention to this blog since May, you would know that I have repeatedly said that Guerrero has been struggling. I’ll say it again, just so there is absolutely no confusion:
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is having an awful season.
There. I said it again.
I have said it time and time again, but somehow there seems to be a disconnect somewhere.
I was born at night, but it wasn’t last night.
I understand how this works. When you are the highest-paid player on the team, you are expected to perform. When you are making that kind of money, the expectations are enormous.
That’s obvious.
Do you want to know what else is obvious?
When you are 29th in baseball in runs scored, you are a bad baseball team.
And that’s exactly what this Toronto Blue Jays team is.
Bad.
Is Vladdy a contributing factor?
Of course he is.
But let me ask you something.
When you watch the Jays this season, and they come to the plate, can you honestly say, “Here comes the clutch hit we need”?
Can you?
Because I can’t.
And apparently, neither can anybody else.
Sure, Kazuma Okamoto has set a rookie franchise record, but he also has one of the highest strikeout rates in baseball. I like Kazuma. I think he has been okay this season.
Look at Ernie Clement. Last season, he set a playoff record with thirty hits. This year, he goes to the All-Star Game.
Great.
It’s a cool honour, especially for your first one.
But in the grand scheme of things, going to the Midsummer Classic means absolutely nothing.
Alek Manoah was an All-Star.
Where is he now?
He’s not even in the league.
If being an All-Star automatically means you are a great player. Nobody should ever criticize Vladimir Guerrero Jr., because he has been an All-Star in every full season he has played in Toronto.
He was even voted in as a starter for this year’s game with the season he has had.
So, no, I am not pretending Vladdy is having a good season.
He isn’t.
But that doesn’t mean I am going to pretend he is the reason this entire baseball team is a disaster.
Because he isn’t.
The problem with the Toronto Blue Jays exists in the dugout and in the front office.
And I’ve had enough of pretending otherwise.
Since 2017, the Blue Jays have finished third or lower in their division every season except last year.
Let that sink in.
Yes, the World Series run last year was incredible. I loved every second of it, just like every other Jays fan.
But we need to be honest with ourselves.
We overachieved last season.
And if you think I’m wrong, then you simply aren’t paying attention.
The Jays came from behind to win 49 games.
Forty-nine!
Do you know what that tells me?
It tells me they were chasing the game 49 times and somehow managed to come back and win.
That isn't something I want to celebrate as evidence that this was a great team.
They got away with it 49 times.
Now go down the street to Scotiabank Arena.
If the Leafs were constantly chasing games and had to come from behind 49 times in a season, people would be screaming from the rooftops.
And you know what?
They would deserve the criticism.
So why are we treating the Jays differently?
This team isn't 29th in runs scored because Vladimir Guerrero Jr. isn't hitting the way we expected him to.
This team is 29th in runs because the team is bad.
Period.
And that falls on Ross Atkins.
Atkins somehow lucked his way into a five-year extension coming off the World Series, but let's not forget who is responsible for the decade of mediocrity that came before it.
If the Blue Jays were a serious organization with serious ownership, Ross Atkins would have been fired years ago.
Instead, here we are.
And now the Jays are two games out of the playoffs after tonight’s embarrassing loss at home to Chris Bassitt and Baltimore.
The shine from last season is officially gone.
If you still believe this team is going to make the playoffs, then hats off to you.
I admire the optimism.
But I don't see it.
And honestly?
This team doesn't deserve to be there.
Ross Atkins has done a terrible job with this team this season, and maybe we need to stop limiting the criticism to this season and start looking at his entire tenure.
I talked about this in my Gate 14 column the other day.
The Jays put all their eggs in the Shohei Ohtani basket.
Ohtani signed with the Dodgers.
What was Ross Atkins' backup plan?
Justin Turner and Paul DeJong.
Then we went all-in on Juan Soto.
Soto signed with the Mets.
This season, we tried to sign either Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger.
Tucker went to the Dodgers.
Bellinger, who I wanted, stayed with the Yankees.
Yes, we managed to sign Dylan Cease, and I will give Atkins credit where credit is due.
Cease has been great.
But doesn't this also tell you something about how Atkins views what wins baseball games?
Sure, pitching is important.
Of course it is.
But you cannot build a baseball team around pitching and then completely forget that you actually have to score runs.
We saw a perfect example tonight during the broadcast.
Joe Siddall talked about Trey Yesavage being close to returning to the Jays and how his return could help Toronto in its push for the playoffs.
And I have one question:
How?
Seriously.
How would Trey Yesavage returning suddenly fix this baseball team?
How?
The short answer is:
He wouldn't.
The Jays could have Nolan Ryan, Roger Clemens and Randy Johnson pitching for us in their primes, and it wouldn't make a damn bit of difference if this team can't hit.
You can't win baseball games if you can't score.
It really isn't that complicated.
So, for the last time, if you want to continue saying that I blindly defend Vladimir Guerrero Jr. regardless of what he does, then go ahead.
I don't care anymore.
You can continue looking at the problem on the surface.
I am going to continue looking at the root of the problem.
Yes, Vladdy is struggling.
Yes, he needs to be better.
But the problems with the Toronto Blue Jays are much bigger than one player.
They begin in the dugout with an inexperienced manager in John Schneider.
They continue in the front office with Ross Atkins.
And they ultimately go even higher.
Because at some point, ownership has to look at this organization and ask the question that every frustrated Jays fan is asking:
How much longer are we going to accept this?
Ross Atkins is the general manager of a baseball team that has spent years failing to live up to expectations.
And yet here he is, still sitting in the front office, captaining the sinking Titanic and telling us everything is fine.
Meanwhile, the rest of us are climbing into the lifeboats.
We're tired.
We're frustrated.
And we're ready for a fresh start.
And personally?
I'll be ready for that fresh start when the Toronto Maple Leafs return at the end of September.



Comments
Post a Comment