Matthew Knies Traded Was John Chayka Right?

 


Photo from the Toronto Sun


Well, the season kicks off tomorrow night, and John Chayka decided he wasn’t going to ease into his first season as general manager of the Toronto Maple Leafs.

He went big.

Last season at the Trade Deadline, we heard that Brad Treliving was just minutes away from trading Matthew Knies to the Montreal Canadiens. The deal never happened, but that certainly didn’t stop the rumours.

All summer long, Knies’ name seemed to be mentioned in just about every Leafs trade rumour imaginable.

Then, today, Elliott Friedman reported that the Leafs were in deep conversations with Columbus about Kirill Marchenko.

That was enough to get Leafs Nation talking.

And then the news dropped.

The Toronto Maple Leafs traded Matthew Knies, Steven Lorentz, defenceman Emil Andrae, and a second-round pick in 2027 to Columbus.

In return, Toronto acquired Kirill Marchenko, Miles Wood, and goaltender Elvis Merzlikins, with Columbus retaining 18% of Merzlikins’ salary. It is also worth mentioning that Merzlikins will spend the season on LTIR.

Now, I know there are going to be a lot of unhappy Leafs fans after this trade.

And you know what?

I understand it.

Matthew Knies is a fan favourite. He plays the kind of physical, hard-nosed game that Leafs fans love, and I’m one of those fans who really likes what he brings to the lineup.

But I don't think Toronto made this trade because they suddenly decided Knies wasn't a good hockey player.

I think they made it because they believe Kirill Marchenko can give them more of what they need right now.

And that's an important distinction.

At the same time, I have to admit that Knies’ preseason didn’t exactly make me feel better about his future with the Leafs.

I felt like Knies looked a step behind everyone else.

Yes, I know it was the preseason. I understand that players aren't necessarily going all-out in September and October exhibition games.

But when you are getting outworked by the Senators’ AHL lineup, that’s not exactly a great sign.

Knies also reportedly came into camp lighter this season.

Then there is the injury history.

Knies has already suffered two concussions, dealt with a knee injury, and played last season while injured.

So I have to ask the question: What happens if Toronto keeps him and he suffers another significant injury?

His trade value could continue to drop.

Do I think Matthew Knies is going to be a good NHL player?

Absolutely.

I have never said otherwise.

But I also believe Kirill Marchenko is an upgrade and, more importantly, could be a better fit alongside Auston Matthews.

And that's where this trade gets really interesting.

Knies had 66 points last season, including 23 goals and 43 assists. Those are very respectable numbers, especially for a player who is still developing.

But Marchenko had 67 points, including 27 goals and 40 assists, while finishing with a plus-7 rating.

Knies, meanwhile, finished the season at minus-30.

Now, before someone jumps down my throat, yes, I understand that Craig Berube’s coaching style and the way the Leafs played had a lot to do with those numbers.

I’m not going to pretend that one statistic tells the entire story.

But numbers still matter.

Marchenko and Knies are listed at the same height, but Marchenko is a much faster skater.

And when you are talking about putting a winger alongside Auston Matthews, that becomes extremely important.

Matthews is one of the best goal scorers in the NHL, but he also needs a winger who can keep up with him, create space, attack with speed and turn a transition opportunity into a scoring chance.

That is where I see Marchenko potentially being a very good fit.

Then there is the goal-scoring potential.

Marchenko scored 27 goals last season while recording 67 points. If he can take another step offensively, I don't think it's unreasonable to see him developing into a 35-to-40-goal scorer.

Imagine having that kind of player beside Auston Matthews.

That is the upside John Chayka is betting on.

And I think that's what we have to look at when evaluating this trade.

Toronto didn't simply trade Matthew Knies for another player with a similar statistical profile.

They traded a young, physical winger for a winger they believe has a higher offensive ceiling and a skill set that could complement their best player.

There is also the question of timing.

The Leafs have Matthews. They have a window they are trying to take advantage of.

At some point, you have to stop looking at what a player might become and start asking what your team needs now.

That's not a knock on Knies.

It is simply the reality of roster construction.

I also think the contract extension makes this trade even more significant.

Toronto didn't acquire Marchenko and decide they would figure out his future later. They acquired him and immediately committed to him for six more years at $12.5 million per season beginning next season.

That tells me this wasn't a short-term gamble.

John Chayka clearly believes Marchenko can become an important part of this team for years to come.

Now, does that mean this trade can't backfire?

Of course not.

Knies could continue developing and become a dominant power forward somewhere else. Marchenko could fail to reach the ceiling Toronto believes he has.

That's the risk with any major NHL trade involving a young player.

But I don't think the question should be, “Did the Leafs give up too much for Marchenko?”

I think the better question is, “Did the Leafs acquire a player who can make their top line and overall roster better?”

And that's where I'm willing to give Chayka the benefit of the doubt.

I think Marchenko has the skating, offensive ability and goal-scoring potential to be a better fit alongside Matthews.

Now, let's talk about the other pieces of the trade.

After Steven Lorentz was placed on waivers and cleared them the other day, I had a feeling it was only a matter of time before he was moved.

Lorentz was another fan favourite, especially because he was a hometown guy, but it became pretty obvious that John Chayka’s additions to the bottom-six forward group were going to create a numbers game.

Unfortunately for Lorentz, he ended up on the outside looking in.

I want to wish him nothing but the best.

Then there’s Miles Wood.

In many ways, Wood is basically another Steven Lorentz.

He is the type of player who can get under the opponent’s skin, play a physical game and make life miserable for the other team.

And Leafs fans have seen plenty of him over the years during Toronto’s battles with the Devils and other teams.

There is also a personal connection for me with Wood.

He is the son of former Leaf Randy Wood, who I remember watching play after Cliff Fletcher brought him to Toronto along with Mike Ridley.

One of Randy Wood’s highlights as a Leaf came in the 1994-95 playoffs when he scored an overtime-winning goal against Chicago after being set up by a young Mats Sundin.

For some reason, I remember that goal like it happened yesterday.

Maybe that’s just the Leafs fan in me.

Emil Andrae is the final piece of the trade to leave Toronto, and honestly, I simply don’t think he did enough in camp to impress the Leafs brass.

Now comes the fun part.

How will Kirill Marchenko fit in Toronto?

We won't have to wait long to find out.

After finalizing the trade, the Leafs signed Marchenko to a six-year extension worth $12.5 million per season beginning next season.

So, hopefully, Leafs fans are looking at a potential Matthews-Marchenko partnership for years to come.

That is a pretty exciting thought.

I know there are going to be people who hate this trade.

I know there are going to be people who think John Chayka gave up too much.

And I completely understand why Leafs fans are upset about losing Matthew Knies.

But sometimes you have to make difficult decisions if you want to improve your hockey team.

For me, this isn't about saying Matthew Knies is a bad hockey player.

He isn't.

It's about believing that Kirill Marchenko gives the Leafs something they need and could ultimately be a better fit for what this team is trying to accomplish.

Maybe I'm wrong.

That's the beauty of being a sports fan.

We can debate it.

We can argue about it.

And then we get to watch the games and find out.

So, Matthew Knies, thank you.

Steven Lorentz, thank you.

Thank you for your time as members of the Toronto Maple Leafs, and I genuinely wish both of you nothing but success moving forward.

As for the Leafs?

Enough talking.

Enough rumours.

Enough preseason hockey.

The season starts tomorrow night.

Let's finally drop the puck.


Comments

Popular Posts