Gate 14 Has a Problem With Me, I'm Not Sure Why

 



Today, I am going to write about something a little different. Apparently, I am involved in a one-sided feud with a Blue Jays podcast called Gate 14.

If you aren’t aware of them, Gate 14 is a Jays-centric podcast that has been around for a few years now. I actually found them during the infamous Shohei Ohtani watch, when Jays fans spent an entire day tracking an airplane because we were convinced Ohtani was flying to Toronto to sign with the Blue Jays.

Of course, it wasn’t Shohei Ohtani.

It was a dragon who happened to be leaving his den.

If you know, you know.

Now, I know many people will read this and think, “Joe, why the hell are you writing about an online beef?”

Honestly, the answer is pretty simple.

I’m bored, and I find it pretty funny.

So, as I said, I found Gate 14 during the Ohtani watch, and I honestly found their videos and streams entertaining. Like me, the two hosts, John and Avery, are passionate about the Toronto Blue Jays, and I have always enjoyed hearing different perspectives from different fans.

That’s what being a sports fan is supposed to be about.

You watch the game, you form an opinion, somebody else has a different opinion, and you debate it.

That’s one of the reasons I started this blog in the first place. I enjoy debate. I enjoy conversation. I enjoy hearing somebody explain why they disagree with me, even if I still think they’re completely wrong afterward.

That’s sports.

So, you’re probably asking, “Okay, Joe, where exactly is the beef?”

I’ll get to it.

And if you caught that 1980s Burger King reference, congratulations. You’re as old as I am.

As many of you know, I started blogging five years ago, and it was originally supposed to be a Maple Leafs-focused blog because, well, the Leafs are and always have been my favourite team.

But heading into the 2025 season, I thought, why not start writing about the Blue Jays?

The summers are usually pretty slow after NHL free agency, so writing about the Jays would give me more content for the site, potentially attract another audience and, hopefully, bring in more readers.

Makes sense, right?

Before I started adding Jays content, I had interacted with Johnny Giunta, the main host of Gate 14, and everything seemed perfectly fine.

We interacted through social media. We had some decent conversations. There was no issue.

And let me make this very clear before I go any further: I think what Johnny and Avery have accomplished with Gate 14 is great.

Seriously.

Getting to sit down with the president of your favourite baseball team and interview him? Having that same president give you a tour of the SkyDome or the team’s complex in Dunedin?

I would absolutely love that.

They have worked hard to build their audience, and they have done some pretty amazing things.

So, no, this isn’t me trying to take anything away from them.

But somewhere along the way, things changed.

I started writing more about the Blue Jays.

My numbers started climbing.

And, for some reason, the interactions became increasingly hostile.

At first, I honestly had no idea why.

I would reach out, and suddenly I was being called a fool or told I was clueless because I questioned John Schneider as a manager.

Or I would ask what was wrong with Ernie Clement, and apparently that was enough to warrant criticism.

I didn’t really understand it.

Then last night, I think I finally figured it out.

Apparently, Johnny has blocked me on pretty much every form of social media.

Which, honestly, I find hilarious.

I mean, congratulations, I guess?

So, let’s get to last night.

In the second inning of the game, I was watching the Gate 14 stream, and Straw challenged what I thought was a clear strike, hoping it was actually a ball.

So I said:

“What a terrible challenge by Straw.”

Apparently, those words were enough to start heating up the kettle.

Later in the game, after Springer had another terrible at-bat, I joked:

“It’s 2024 all over again. We can’t hit, and it’s torture.”

Well, the kettle didn’t just boil.

It exploded.

Apparently, I am a loser who lives in my mom’s basement and has never watched baseball in my life.

Now, the joke is on Johnny because I actually live on the ground floor of my house.

Not the basement.

So there’s that.

But somewhere between being called clueless and being told I apparently know nothing about baseball, I realized what I think the real issue is.

Johnny is friends with John Schneider.

Johnny was also invited to celebrate last year’s ALCS win with the team.

And apparently, because of that relationship, criticizing John Schneider or criticizing a player for making a mistake somehow becomes a personal attack.

You can’t criticize a player because that might hurt Johnny’s feelings.

You can’t criticize John Schneider because he’s Johnny’s friend.

And apparently, if you do, you’re a fool.

I have to be honest, that is a pretty strange way to run a sports platform.

Johnny, I know the chances of you seeing this, let alone reading it, are about as slim as the Jays’ playoff hopes right now.

But if you do happen to see this, I want you to do something for me.

Find a mirror.

Look at the man staring back at you and ask yourself one simple question:

Are you happy?

Because I genuinely have no idea what your issue with me is.

But you clearly have one.

And, quite frankly, I’m probably just another name on whatever imaginary enemies list you have written down somewhere.

The funny thing is, I have been nothing but positive toward you and your podcast.

When you had your Gate 14 nights at the Dome, I actually tried to get to your section just so I could shake your hand and congratulate you on everything you guys had accomplished.

I was a fan.

I still think you guys have done some great things.

But somewhere along the way, it seems you started carrying yourself like you’re the king of Blue Jays fandom.

You’re not.

And neither am I.

You’re a fan.

Just like me.

The only difference is that I watched Toronto win two World Series while you were still filling your diaper.

But guess what?

We still have something in common.

We’re both fans of the same damn team.

I want the Blue Jays to win just as badly as you do.

I want them to succeed.

I want them to make the playoffs.

I want them to win another World Series.

But just because I don’t think John Schneider is a good manager doesn’t make me a fool.

It doesn’t make me clueless.

And it certainly doesn’t mean I don’t know baseball.

It means I have a different opinion than you.

That’s it.

And here’s the thing about having an online platform: if you are going to invite people to interact with you, you have to be prepared for those people to disagree with you.

You can’t only want interaction when everyone is telling you how great you are.

You can’t ask for people’s opinions and then lose your mind when someone actually gives you one.

I cleaned up some of what I originally wanted to say because I know kids read my articles, but the basic point remains the same.

If you are going to continue losing your cool every time somebody criticizes a player, a manager or the organization, eventually people are going to stop wanting to interact with you.

And that’s the irony of this whole thing.

You built a platform around being a fan.

I built a platform around being a fan.

We both love the Blue Jays.

We both want the Blue Jays to win.

We both spend far too much time talking about the Blue Jays.

The difference is that I understand something you apparently don’t:

Being a fan doesn’t mean you have to blindly agree with everything the team does.

I can criticize John Schneider and still support the Blue Jays.

I can criticize a player and still cheer for that player.

I can say Straw made a terrible challenge and still hope he gets a big hit the next night.

That’s what being a fan is.

So, Johnny, if you happen to read this, congratulations on everything you and Avery have accomplished with Gate 14.

Seriously.

You’ve built something that a lot of fans would love to have.

But maybe it’s time to take a step back and ask yourself what kind of platform you actually want to run.

Because if you’re going to invite fans into the conversation, you need to understand that not every fan is going to agree with you.

And if a simple disagreement over a baseball player or a manager is enough to make you angry, block somebody and start calling them names, maybe the problem isn’t the fan.

Maybe it’s you.

So I’ll leave you with one final question.

You asked for the interaction.

You got it.

Why are you so angry about it?

Comments

Popular Posts