Vladdy Isn't the Only Problem
Photo From Toronto Sun
This frustrating season for the Blue Jays can’t end fast enough for me.
After losing Tuesday night to the Kansas City Royals, Toronto currently sits 2.5 games behind the final playoff spot. Obviously, I will follow this season until the end, hoping Toronto makes it, but I don’t know if it’s going to happen.
All season long, we have heard, “Vladdy is struggling.”
Like, it isn’t obvious.
I have had conversations with friends and other fans about why I think Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has struggled. To me, a big part of the problem is simple: there are no other threatening bats in this lineup.
I already know what the response is going to be.
“It’s the same lineup as last year.”
In fact, I was told exactly that tonight during the game.
Let me explain what I mean by there being no threatening bat in the lineup.
Last season, from June until the end of the season, the Jays were one of, if not the best-hitting teams in the American League.
Why?
Because one through nine in the order could make a difference.
George Springer had a career year. Dalton Varsho was making a difference. Ernie Clement was making a difference. Lukes was making a difference, and so on.
Each at-bat last season was patient and disciplined. They would take a walk if it was given to them. Each hitter would work into a hitter’s count. They made opposing pitchers work.
This season?
For some reason, they swing at almost every pitch.
The Jays, as a matter of fact, have had one of the highest chase rates in the league. Their offence has been near the bottom of baseball all season.
What does this have to do with Guerrero?
I think Vladdy is trying to force something to happen because he knows this team needs him.
He is pressing.
He is chasing pitches he would normally take. Opposing pitchers have picked up on this and are pitching to him knowing he will chase or make weak contact.
Think back to the 2015 and 2016 seasons for Toronto.
If teams walked Jose Bautista, they would have to face Josh Donaldson or Edwin Encarnacion, and so on.
It was a game of pick your poison for opposing pitchers.
Do we have that this season for the Jays?
Not even close.
I was also told tonight that the Jays should send Guerrero to Double-A New Hampshire.
Here is why that won’t benefit Guerrero at all.
He would simply overpower pitchers at that level because of his experience and talent.
Just look at his rehab game the other night with Dunedin. In his first at-bat, he sent a double to the wall. After that, he was walked in his next two plate appearances.
What exactly is he supposed to learn from that?
Sending Vladdy down to the minors would be like the Leafs sending Easton Cowan back to the London Knights for this coming season.
He would overpower the competition, and it wouldn’t benefit his game at all.
The same goes for Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
So, what should the Jays do?
I think they need to slide their franchise player down the batting order until he can string something together.
Let him take some pressure off himself. Let him see some better pitches. Let him get some confidence back.
For some reason, with a month left in the season, John Schneider has yet to try this.
And that’s where I feel one of the biggest issues sits for the Toronto Blue Jays.
There is no accountability.
Just go back to the Tampa Bay series and the costly fielding error. After the game, when asked about the play and the struggles of Jesus Sanchez, the manager answered:
“He tries really hard.”
John, to steal a phrase from Josh Donaldson:
“This isn’t the try-hard league; it’s the get-it-done league.”
I’m not blaming John Schneider for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. struggling.
The manager can’t step into the batter’s box and hit for him.
What I am blaming Schneider for is watching his franchise player struggle for months and continuing to do the same thing, hoping the problem will somehow fix itself.
That is where a manager has to earn his money.
A good manager recognizes when something isn’t working and tries something different.
Maybe moving Vladdy down the lineup works.
Maybe it doesn’t.
But why not try it?
What exactly is there to lose at this point?
The Blue Jays have 29 games left in this season. This isn’t April. There aren’t another five months to figure things out.
The time for simply hoping things turn around is over.
If Schneider believes keeping Vladdy in the same spot is the best option, fine.
Then explain why.
Show the fans that there is a plan.
But simply continuing to do the same thing while expecting a different result isn’t managing.
It’s hoping.
And that is why I have such a problem with the lack of accountability on this team.
If John Schneider moved Vladdy down the order, maybe Guerrero would respond. Maybe he would relax. Maybe he would start performing like the hitter we all know he can be.
Instead, Schneider continues to put him in the same spot and expects something different to happen.
That is the definition of insanity.
John Schneider seems more focused on being everyone’s friend than being the manager of the Toronto Blue Jays.
I don’t expect him to embarrass his players in front of the media. I don’t expect him to throw them under the bus after every loss.
But there is a difference between supporting your players and refusing to hold them accountable.
You can support a player while still telling him, “You need to be better.”
You can defend a player while still changing his role when what he is doing isn’t working.
And you can be a player’s friend without forgetting that your job is to manage a baseball team.
That’s what I think is missing with this Blue Jays team.
I’m not blaming John Schneider for every problem this team has. I’m blaming him for failing to make adjustments when the problems become obvious.
That’s what a manager is supposed to do.
And right now, I don’t see enough of it.
A lack of accountability is nothing new when it comes to sports in the city of Toronto.
Just go back and look at Sheldon Keefe when he coached the Maple Leafs.
Anytime he would try to hold a member of the Core Four accountable after a game when speaking to the media, it seemed like the next day he would publicly apologize for what was said.
Without accountability, there is no incentive to work because you know things are going to remain the same for you.
If people truly think that Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is going to perform like this for the rest of his contract, you are simply out of your mind.
He is too talented not to be a better player for the Blue Jays.
If anyone wants to continue thinking that he will never hit a baseball again or that he is the worst player in the world, go ahead, because you are probably the same people who thought letting Chris Bassitt go in free agency while bringing back a 42-year-old Max Scherzer was a great idea.
Again, the Toronto Blue Jays are the worst-hitting team in baseball, and that’s not simply because of one player.
Yes, Vladdy is a contributing factor.
I’m not going to pretend he isn’t.
But when you are struggling like the Jays have been all season, then you should turn your focus to the hitting coaches and wonder why they haven’t been able to make the necessary adjustments.
Also, look to Ross Atkins and ask why he made some of the moves he did.
Anthony Santander signed for $90 million and hasn’t played a game this season.
Don’t worry.
The Ross Atkins write-up is coming in the future.
Twenty-nine games remain in this Jays season.
Will they make the playoffs?
My heart says yes.
Of course it does.
I’m a Blue Jays fan.
But my head says…
Hockey season starts in a month.



Comments
Post a Comment