Know the Situation
This column is going to be a little different than my usual one. I’m not here to rip a player, blame the manager, or complain about the bullpen. I want to talk about something that applies to every sport: knowing the situation.
This is something I learned years ago when I was a volunteer coach with the Newmarket Hurricanes hockey team. It was drilled into us constantly. Know the score, know the time, know the momentum, and know what matters most in that moment. The more I watch baseball, the more I realize how often that lesson gets ignored.
Monday night was a perfect example.
The Blue Jays came home to open a massive four-game series against a red-hot Boston Red Sox team. In the top of the second inning, Jameson Taillon threw a pitch on a 0-0 count and clearly out of the strike zone. Brandon Valenzuela challenged it, and he lost. Then in the seventh inning, on another 0-0 count, Woods Richardson missed the zone, Valenzuela challenged again, and he lost again.
A lot of people will probably read this and say, “Joe, who cares? It was only a challenge.”
That’s exactly the point. In a playoff race, there is no such thing as “only a challenge.”
Both challenges came on the first pitch of the at-bat. Both pitches were obviously balls. The count became 1-0, and the game moved on. The focus should have been on making the next pitch, not wasting one of your most valuable resources trying to steal strike one on a pitch that was never close.
And here’s where knowing the situation really matters.
Later in the game, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. came up in a huge spot. He was ahead in the count, and a pitch that should have been ball four was called a strike. If the Blue Jays had kept one of those challenges, Vladdy challenges the call, wins it, and the bases are loaded for George Springer with one out.
Now the entire at-bat changes.
Springer can sit on a pitch. The pitcher has to come to him. The Red Sox are thinking double play, which means they are likely pitching accordingly. George can look for something he can drive instead of protecting in a completely different count situation.
That’s what I mean by knowing the situation. The challenge is not about the second inning. It’s about what you might need in the eighth.
There’s another example that still bothers me from the end of Game 7 of the World Series.
Alejandro Kirk came to the plate with one out and a runner on first. Last season, when Kirk got a pitch up in the zone, he was very likely to lift the baseball and do something positive for the Blue Jays. The Dodgers knew it too.
So what did they do?
Yamamoto pounded the bottom of the strike zone. He knew that if Kirk made contact, he would probably get on top of the baseball and hit it on the ground. With Kirk’s lack of speed, that creates a perfect double-play situation.
And what happened?
Ground ball. Double play. Game over.
The Dodgers understood the situation better than the hitter did, and it won them the championship.
This is why I get so frustrated when I see players burn challenges early in games. It has nothing to do with hating Brandon Valenzuela, and it has nothing to do with hating this team. I was accused Monday night of hating everyone on the Blue Jays, and honestly, that couldn’t be further from the truth.
I care about this team, which is exactly why these moments frustrate me.
When you’re fighting for your playoff life, every pitch matters, every challenge matters, every out matters, and every decision matters. Good teams don’t just have talent. Good teams understand the moment they are in.
Sometimes the difference between winning and losing is not a home run, a strikeout, or a diving catch.
Sometimes it’s simply knowing the situation.



Comments
Post a Comment