Jays Add Soriano
Photo From Sportsnet
Less than 24 hours after trading Kevin Gausman, most of us thought the Blue Jays were beginning a full sell-off.
Instead, Ross Atkins turned around and bought a pitcher.
The Blue Jays have acquired José Soriano from the Los Angeles Angels, and the price was not small. Toronto gave up Arjun Nimmala, the organization’s No. 2 prospect, along with two other players.
If you were looking for another reason why I have little confidence in Ross Atkins as the general manager of this team, this trade is a pretty good place to start.
Before people jump on me, let me make something clear: José Soriano is not a bad pitcher. In fact, he has been quite solid this season. He is 9–6 on a bad Angels team; he has electric stuff, his breaking pitches have excellent movement, and there is team control remaining on his contract. I would not be surprised if the Jays view him as a long-term piece of the rotation.
But that is not really the point.
The point is that the Blue Jays have the worst offence in baseball, and they just traded their second-best prospect without getting a future impact bat in return.
That is the part I cannot understand.
Soriano’s biggest issue has always been command. He walks too many hitters, and that has followed him throughout his career. I keep seeing people say, “Pete Walker will fix him.”
Maybe he will.
But can we stop acting as if Pete Walker is some untouchable pitching genius? If he were truly the best pitching coach in baseball, other organizations would be lining up every offseason trying to hire him away. He has done good work in Toronto, but not every pitcher who arrives here suddenly becomes an ace.
What makes this trade even harder to swallow is the timing.
You trade Kevin Gausman, a pitcher who embraced Toronto and gave everything he had to this team, and then the next morning you turn around and move one of your best prospects for another arm.
It feels like this front office still has no clear direction.
And the moves did not stop there.
The Jays also made a trade with the Texas Rangers, sending Adam Macko to Texas. In return, Toronto receives minor-league pitcher Josh Stephan, who has struggled in Triple-A Round Rock with a 5.88 ERA, and utility hitter Josh Smith, who is batting .213 with one home run and eight RBIs.
I understand that when a team is selling, not every return is going to be exciting. I get that.
What I do not get is why I am supposed to believe that Ross Atkins is the executive who can lead this franchise back to contention.
That is where my frustration is coming from.
This is not just about one trade. It is about the bigger picture.
Since 2017, this organization has consistently fallen short of expectations. The offence has become a major problem, the roster construction has been questioned for years, and yet the man in charge was rewarded with a five-year extension.
So while some fans are trying to convince themselves that Soriano is the next great Blue Jays pitcher, I keep coming back to the same question:
Who is going to hit?
Because right now, this team cannot score runs, and trading away one of your top prospects without adding a meaningful future bat does not look like a plan to fix that problem.
Maybe Soriano becomes a very good starter in Toronto.
Maybe Nimmala never reaches his ceiling.
Baseball is unpredictable.
But today, as a Blue Jays fan, this feels less like a smart long-term move and more like another gamble from a front office that has already lost too many of them.
And honestly, I cannot shake the feeling that last year’s World Series run may end up being the exception rather than the beginning of something bigger.



Comments
Post a Comment