John Schneider is Not the Guy

 


Photo From MLB

The Toronto Blue Jays are 46-54 this season.

For a team that entered the season with World Series aspirations, 46-54 is simply unacceptable.

John Schneider played zero games in Major League Baseball. DeMarlo Hale played zero MLB games. David Popkins also played zero MLB games. Nobody on this coaching staff has dealt with struggles at this level as a player.

Meanwhile, Don Mattingly is 47-26 with the Phillies. We clearly kept the wrong guy. Don has decades of experience as a player. He has gone through slumps, and he knows how to get out of them. The Phillies are once again a National League contender after making a coaching change.

Then look at the AL East this season. The Boston Red Sox got off to a slow start, management fired the entire coaching staff, and look at them now. They've won 14 straight games and are probably the hottest team in the division.

Since John Schneider was named manager of this team, I've said over and over again that he wasn't the right guy. I was told I was wrong. I was told I was clueless.

Yes, we made the playoffs last year, and it was an unbelievable run. We came from behind to win 49 games. But you can't always play catch-up, and this season has proven that.

If people really think John Schneider isn't a bad manager, then answer me this: Why was he only given a two-year extension? If Rogers truly believed he was the right manager for the long term, wouldn't they have given him a longer contract?

Ross Atkins doesn't escape blame either. He built a flawed roster.

Letting Bo Bichette go was the right move, but failing to replace his bat was a huge mistake. The Anthony Santander contract has been awful. Letting Chris Bassitt walk while bringing back a 41-year-old Max Scherzer was ridiculous. That was another move I was told I was wrong for criticizing.

Jays fans, how's Max's season going?

Last season, this Blue Jays team consistently lengthened at-bats, forcing opposing starters to throw more pitches and getting into the bullpen early, which paid dividends later in the series.

This year, that entire approach has disappeared.

Ernie Clement swings at everything, including pitches that aren't even close to the strike zone. When your hitting coach and your manager publicly admit that the team struggles to hit fastballs, that's on you to fix it.

In 1989, much like this season, the Blue Jays entered the year with high expectations but got off to a poor start. What did Pat Gillick do?

He fired manager Jimmy Williams and named Cito Gaston the interim manager.

Suddenly, everything changed.

With 126 games remaining, Gaston led the Blue Jays to a 77-49 record and an AL East title. Toronto stuck with him, and the rest is history as the Blue Jays went on to win back-to-back World Series championships.

Why did Cito Gaston work as a manager?

Because he connected with his players.

He had experienced the ups and downs of playing in the major leagues. He knew when players needed encouragement, and he knew when they needed a tough conversation. If a player didn't respond, the organization moved on.

Just ask Derek Bell.

John Schneider seems more interested in being one of the boys than being the guy in charge. Every press conference, he's dropping F-bombs and trying to sound like one of the players. That's great if you're trying to win a popularity contest. Unfortunately, he's trying to win baseball games.

Well, John, since you like F-bombs so much, here's one for you.

You fucking suck as a manager, and you always have.

Sadly, nobody seems to recognize it because so many Blue Jays fans are still caught up in last year's Game 7 of the World Series.

Don't get me wrong. Last year's run was incredible, and it still hurts to think about how it ended.

But 1992 and 1993 were better.

Do you know why?

Because we won.

Why did we win?

Because we had a manager with experience. Cito Gaston had an open-door policy with his players, but he also knew when it was time to be tough. He earned their respect, and to this day, many of those players still speak highly of him.

Many younger Blue Jays fans have no idea just how special those two World Series championships were for fans like me who lived through them.

Those players are still heroes in this city.

Joe Carter was in Toronto on Saturday for the unveiling of his statue. I was there, and the crowd was deafening. There were fans with tears in their eyes.

Myself included.

Why?

Because they remember exactly where they were when Mike Timlin fielded Otis Nixon's bunt for the final out in Atlanta and heard the words, "For the first time ever, the World Series banner will fly north of the border."

Or they remember 1993, when Tom Cheek's unforgettable words echoed across Canada:

"Touch 'em all, Joe! You'll never hit a bigger home run in your life!"

After Joe Carter's home run sailed over the left-field wall, the Blue Jays were World Series champions once again.

Fans like me get emotional because we'd give anything to experience that feeling again.

Last year, we thought that moment might finally be coming back.

Instead, what we hoped would become a dream season has turned into a nightmare that doesn't seem to want to end.

Until this organization learns from its past, the memories of 1992 and 1993 will continue to feel a lot closer than the next World Series championship.

Comments

Popular Posts