From Dream to Nightmare

 


For 85 minutes, I thought England was going to the World Cup Final. Then everything fell apart.

On Wednesday, England faced Argentina in the World Cup semi-final, and as an England supporter, I was stressing over the game all day. As the first 45 minutes came to an end, I was confident England was going to book its place in Sunday's final.

In the 55th minute, Anthony Gordon put England ahead 1-0, and my heart rate immediately skyrocketed. As the second half wound down, Argentina began pressing, but England seemed to be holding on. Then it happened. Argentina found the equalizer, and in stoppage time, they scored the winner.

What started as a dream ended in heartbreak.

This loss hurts, and it will hurt for a long time. But as painful as the defeat was, what bothered me even more was the reaction from parts of the English media.

Let's focus on Joe Hart and Wayne Rooney, who were working on the BBC broadcast. Almost immediately after the final whistle, they were questioning Thomas Tuchel and suggesting England's manager deserved much of the blame.

It's always easy to point the finger at the manager after a loss. But where were these same critics when England came from behind to beat Congo in the Round of 32? Where were they when England held on to beat Mexico at the Azteca? Or when England defeated Norway in the quarter-finals?

At that point, Thomas Tuchel could do no wrong. England loses one match, and suddenly it's, "He has to be sacked."

That's ridiculous.

If you've read my column about my love for football, you'll know I absolutely love Manchester United and always will. Wayne Rooney was my favourite player growing up. I loved watching him play. As a Manchester United player, he was phenomenal. He worked tirelessly every match and won virtually every trophy there was to win.

Nobody can question Wayne Rooney's playing career. He's one of the greatest footballers England has ever produced.

But being a great player doesn't automatically make you a great manager. Those are two completely different jobs.

Joe Hart was critical, too, but Rooney's comments stood out the most because he has actually managed professionally. If you're going to criticize Thomas Tuchel's coaching ability, then it's only fair that we examine your own managerial résumé.

Here's Wayne Rooney's record as a manager:

  • Derby County: 24 wins, 22 draws, 39 losses (28.2% win percentage)
  • D.C. United: 14 wins, 14 draws, 25 losses (26.4% win percentage)
  • Birmingham City: 2 wins, 4 draws, 9 losses (13.3% win percentage)
  • Plymouth Argyle: 5 wins, 6 draws, 14 losses (20.0% win percentage)

That's 45 wins in 178 matches.

A 25.3 percent win rate.

Those numbers don't exactly scream managerial genius.

So, should Wayne Rooney really be criticizing how Thomas Tuchel managed this tournament or this semi-final?

As a player, Rooney earned the respect of football fans everywhere, including mine. He'll always be remembered as a Manchester United legend, and Sir Alex Ferguson deserves enormous credit for helping him become one of the best players of his generation.

But Thomas Tuchel has won league titles, domestic cups, the UEFA Champions League, and has managed some of the biggest clubs in world football. He's proven himself at the highest level as a manager. Rooney simply hasn't.

Am I disappointed England won't be playing in the World Cup Final on Sunday?

Absolutely.

But I'm also incredibly proud of what this team accomplished, and of the job Thomas Tuchel has done in such a short period as England manager.

England now turns its attention to Saturday's third-place match against France. Some people will dismiss that game, but I won't. If you're a true England supporter, you back your country every time they step onto the pitch. There is absolutely nothing wrong with trying to bring home a bronze medal.

To the critics in the English media calling for Tuchel to lose his job, and to the armchair managers on YouTube shouting from their moms' basements, maybe it's time to take a step back and look at the bigger picture.

One heartbreaking night doesn't erase everything England accomplished during this tournament.

I still believe Thomas Tuchel is the right man for the job, and I truly believe he'll be the manager who finally leads England to a major international trophy.

And when that day comes, many of the same people calling for his job today will be praising every decision he makes.

Wednesday night hurt. It probably will for a long time.

But heartbreak is part of being a football supporter.

I'll be back cheering for England against France on Saturday, and I'll be back supporting them at the next tournament too.

Because that's what fans do.

Comments

Popular Posts