Unexpected, But Worth a Chance

 


Photo from the LA Times

This morning, the Toronto Maple Leafs announced their new head coach, and it's a name I'm sure no Leaf fan was expecting. John Chayka has hired Jim Hiller as the next bench boss of the Toronto Maple Leafs, and if you're like me, your first reaction was probably, "Well, that wasn't on my bingo card."

Hiller is hardly an unknown around Toronto. He served as an assistant coach under Mike Babcock before moving on to the New York Islanders. After three seasons on Long Island, he joined the Los Angeles Kings, where he once again worked as an assistant before being promoted to head coach in February 2024.

During his interim run behind the Kings' bench, Hiller guided Los Angeles to a 21-12-1 record in 34 games, good for a .632 winning percentage. The Kings were eliminated by the Edmonton Oilers in the first round, but let's be honest: if your goaltending tandem is Cam Talbot and Dave Rittich, you're probably not winning a Stanley Cup. What mattered was that Hiller stepped into a difficult situation and immediately got results.

The following season, his first full year as head coach, the Kings finished 48-25-9 with 105 points, good enough for second place in the Pacific Division. Unfortunately, thanks to Gary Bettman's beloved playoff format, Los Angeles once again found itself staring at Connor McDavid and the Edmonton Oilers in Round One. The result was familiar, as the Oilers advanced in six games.

After the season, the Kings made a change in the front office, replacing franchise legend Rob Blake with Ken Holland. At that point, I have to wonder if Hiller felt like he was coaching on borrowed time. Fair or not, new general managers often want their own people behind the bench. Despite Holland's long résumé, I've felt for a while that his best days may be behind him. Keeping an aging roster together for as long as he did in Edmonton certainly raised some questions.

When Hiller was relieved of his duties on March 1, many people assumed the Kings must have been falling apart. That wasn't the case. In his final 59 games, Los Angeles posted a record of 24-21-14. Not spectacular, but hardly a disaster. The team remained above .500, which makes his dismissal look more like a philosophical change than a performance-based one.

Overall, Hiller finished his time in Los Angeles with a record of 93-58-24 in 175 games, good for a .600 winning percentage. Those aren't the numbers of a coach who has no idea what he's doing. This is someone who has spent years working his way through the ranks and earning opportunities.

Now, I'll be honest. Jim Hiller wasn't my first choice.

Anyone who has read my work knows I was firmly in the Bruce Cassidy camp. Unfortunately, Vegas apparently decided they would rather pay Cassidy to sit at home than allow him to coach another team. That's their decision, and there's nothing Toronto could do about it.

So where does that leave us?

It leaves us with a coach who has NHL experience, a history with the organization, and a track record that suggests he can get results. More importantly, it gives us someone who isn't walking into Toronto with a reputation built solely on hype. Hiller has had to earn everything he's received.

When he was an assistant coach with the Leafs from 2015 to 2019, Toronto consistently iced one of the league's most dangerous offensive teams. While coaching staffs are never one-person operations, Hiller played a role in helping develop some of the young talent that turned the Leafs into a perennial playoff team.

Would I have preferred Cassidy? Absolutely.

Am I willing to give Jim Hiller a chance? Also absolutely.

At the end of the day, every coaching hire comes with uncertainty. No one knew if Craig Berube would be the right fit when he arrived. No one knew if Sheldon Keefe was ready when he was promoted. The same applies here.

The Leafs have made their choice. Now it's up to Jim Hiller to prove it was the right one.

We'll see what happens next in Leaf land.

Comments

Popular Posts