The First Splash of the Summer Leaves Leafs Fans Stunned

 



Photos From Sportsnet

Well, the first splash of the summer has arrived, and it comes courtesy of the Toronto Maple Leafs.

The Leafs announced they have traded Joseph Woll and Simon Benoit to the Philadelphia Flyers in exchange for defenseman Emil Andrae, goaltender Samuel Ersson, and a third-round pick in this year's draft.

My initial reaction?

Shock.

Not anger. Not excitement. Just shock.

I don't think Joseph Woll's name was on many people's trade bingo cards this summer, and judging by the reaction online, there are plenty of Leaf fans who are still trying to process this one.

Now, before anybody grabs the pitchforks, let me say this: I don't hate the trade.

I was a huge Joseph Woll fan. When healthy, he showed flashes of being the goalie Leafs fans have been dreaming about for years. Calm, athletic, technically sound, and capable of stealing games when he was locked in.

The problem, unfortunately, has always been the same.

Health.

It feels like every time Woll started building momentum, something would happen.

Think back to Sheldon Keefe's final season behind the Leafs bench. Going into Game 7 against Boston, Woll had come in and completely changed the series. He looked like the guy who could finally exorcise some playoff demons.

Then, seemingly out of nowhere, the news broke that he couldn't play.

That moment pretty much summed up the Joseph Woll experience in Toronto.

The talent was never the issue.

Availability was.

To his credit, Woll followed that up with a terrific season under Craig Berube, posting a 27-14-1 record and looking like he was finally ready to take control of the Leafs crease.

Then came this past season.

He missed training camp for personal reasons, and let me be clear, I will never criticize a player for taking care of himself or stepping away when necessary. Hockey is important, but life comes first.

Still, once the season got underway, the results simply weren't there.

Woll finished the year with a 15-16-7 record and a .899 save percentage, and when he represented the United States at the World Championships, the struggles continued. In three appearances, he posted a 4.65 goals-against average and a .761 save percentage.

That's not the Joseph Woll we had hoped to see.

Maybe a fresh start is exactly what he needs.

I genuinely hope it works out for him because there is a very good goalie somewhere in there.

As for Simon Benoit, Flyer fans are probably going to love him.

He plays a hard, physical game, isn't afraid to throw his body around, and will do the dirty work that coaches appreciate.

Two years ago, Benoit put together a solid campaign with 10 points in 78 games and looked like he was becoming a dependable depth defender. Last season wasn't nearly as successful, as he finished with just six points and a minus-22 rating.

Like Woll, maybe he simply needs a change of scenery.

From Toronto's perspective, moving both contracts creates more than five million dollars in cap space, and anytime you can create flexibility while adding a draft pick, that's worth noting.

But what about the return?

Let's start with Emil Andrae.

Leaf fans have spent what feels like the last decade begging for a true puck-moving defenseman.

Andrae may not be a household name, but he brings exactly that skill set.

The 24-year-old left-shot defenseman is known for moving the puck efficiently, and after watching the Leafs struggle repeatedly to get the puck out of their own zone last season, that's something that immediately catches my attention.

Andrae recorded 13 points and a plus-15 rating on the Flyers' blue line last season, and if he can help Toronto transition the puck cleaner and generate more offence from the back end, that's a welcome addition.

Let's be honest, Morgan Rielly used to fill that role.

The problem is that the Morgan Rielly of today isn't the same Morgan Rielly of five or six years ago.

And no, before anyone starts, I'm not trying to fuel more Morgan Rielly trade rumours. There are already enough of those floating around.

Then there's Samuel Ersson.

If Woll was a question mark because of health, Ersson is a question mark because of consistency.

His NHL numbers don't exactly jump off the page.

Last season, he went 14-11-5 with a 3.12 goals-against average and an .870 save percentage. The year before, he posted a 22-17-5 record with a 3.14 goals-against average and an .883 save percentage.

Those aren't numbers that make you immediately feel warm and fuzzy.

But here's where things get interesting.

Whenever Ersson puts on a Swedish jersey, he seems to transform into a completely different goalie.

At the Four Nations Face-Off, he made one appearance and earned a win while posting a .970 save percentage.

Then at the World Championships, he was outstanding, going 4-0 with a 1.16 goals-against average and a .934 save percentage.

So, which goalie is the real Samuel Ersson?

Honestly, I have no idea.

But that's what makes him intriguing.

The talent is clearly there.

The Leafs just have to figure out how to get it out of him consistently.

Of course, there is also the organizational depth to consider.

Denis Hildeby had another strong year with the Marlies, and Artur Akhtyamov has been nothing short of fantastic. Watching him backstop the Marlies to within two wins of a Calder Cup championship has given Leafs fans plenty of reasons to be optimistic about the future.

So maybe this move isn't just about replacing Joseph Woll.

Maybe it's about reshaping the entire goaltending picture moving forward.

Only time will tell.

For now, this is one of those trades that probably won't be judged today.

It will be judged a year from now.

Maybe two.

As for Joseph Woll and Simon Benoit, thank you both for your time in Toronto. You represented the Maple Leaf with professionalism, and there were certainly some memorable moments along the way.

Best of luck in Philadelphia.

Unless you're playing the Leafs, of course.

Comments

Popular Posts