Morgan Rielly, Reality, and the Problem with Leafs Nation
Photo From Sportsnet
I want to take some time to give my thoughts on the Morgan Rielly situation because, quite frankly, I think a lot of Leafs fans are losing the plot.
All last season, and pretty much every day since the Leafs were eliminated, sports radio hosts, television panels, and social media "insiders" have been telling us the same thing: it's time for the Leafs to move on from Morgan Rielly.
Maybe they're right.
Maybe they're wrong.
What bothers me isn't the discussion itself. What bothers me is how many fans hear an opinion on television or read a tweet online and immediately accept it as fact.
Let's start with one thing that should not even be debatable: Morgan Rielly has been a loyal soldier for this organization.
He's the longest-serving Maple Leaf. He's played through good times, bad times, rebuilds, playoff heartbreaks, coaching changes, management changes, and everything in between. Has his game declined over the years? Absolutely. Guess what? That's what happens when athletes get older. Time catches up to everyone eventually.
What I find amusing is when fans criticize him for his contract.
If someone walked into your workplace tomorrow and offered you $7.5 million a year, every single one of us would sign that contract before the ink dried. If you say otherwise, you're lying to yourself.
The contract isn't Morgan Rielly's fault.
The player didn't negotiate against himself.
For years, I've heard people say, "The Leafs have to move this guy," simply because television personalities said so. Just because a network decides a player should go doesn't mean it should happen or that it will happen.
As a reminder, Darren Dreger has spent what feels like William Nylander's entire Leafs career suggesting it might be time to move him. I'm not bringing that up to take another shot at TSN's offseason batting average. I'm bringing it up because fans need to start looking at the facts, looking at the numbers, and forming opinions of their own.
What really made me shake my head this week was watching some fans get angry at Morgan Rielly for not waiving his no-movement clause.
Ironically, many of those same fans were furious years ago whenever anyone suggested Mats Sundin should waive his clause.
Remember that situation?
People still talk about it today, yet if you read Sundin's book or listened to his retirement speech, he made it clear he was never approached about waiving his clause. Not once. In fact, Sundin said he would have considered doing it if management had asked him.
So if you're still upset about that situation, direct your anger toward John Ferguson Jr. for handing out the clause or Cliff Fletcher for never approaching him. Mats simply exercised a right that management gave him.
Morgan Rielly is in the exact same position.
He has earned the right to control his future.
Every time the media asks him about waiving, his answer is essentially the same.
"I want to be here."
"I want to be part of the solution."
Does that sound like someone desperately looking for the exit?
Now, do I personally think it's time for the Leafs to explore moving him?
Yes.
But that's different from demanding he waive his clause simply because fans want him gone.
The truth is that fans don't run hockey teams. Thank goodness for that, because if Leafs Nation were in charge of transactions, this organization would be an absolute disaster.
The latest round of hysteria started when random accounts on Twitter claimed Morgan Rielly had agreed to waive his clause. Then Chris Johnston reported that it wasn't the case.
Imagine that.
People on Twitter were wrong.
Again.
Then Dave Pagnotta reported that Toronto wasn't expected to ask Rielly for a list of acceptable destinations and would instead take a team-by-team approach.
Naturally, some fans immediately interpreted that as Morgan refusing to cooperate.
But that's not what was reported.
A team-by-team approach simply means the Leafs will see what offers become available. If John Chayka receives an offer he likes, he'll take it to Rielly and ask whether he'd be willing to waive for that specific destination.
It's not complicated.
It's actually how these situations often work.
At the end of the day, nobody outside the organization knows what Morgan Rielly is thinking. Nobody knows what the Leafs are planning. Yet every day, social media is filled with people confidently declaring they know exactly what's going to happen.
The reality is they don't.
Personally, I think moving Morgan Rielly makes sense.
But I also wouldn't be remotely surprised if he's standing on the blue line for the Leafs on opening night in October.
And before everyone rushes to push him out the door, consider something.
Forget the contract for a moment.
What happens if the next head coach puts Rielly in a different role?
What happens if he plays fewer minutes?
What happens if he's no longer being asked to carry responsibilities that don't fit where he is at this stage of his career?
We've seen this story before.
Think back to Dion Phaneuf.
When he arrived from Calgary, Leafs fans thought they were getting a dominant number-one defenseman. For a brief period, it looked that way. But as his workload increased, the flaws became more noticeable. Eventually, it became clear that Phaneuf wasn't the elite top-pairing defender many believed he was.
Morgan Rielly might be in a similar situation today.
The difference is that his contract still reflects the player he used to be.
I honestly believe that if Morgan were making $3 million or $4 million a season, a lot of the criticism would disappear overnight.
Again, that's not his fault.
The player accepted the contract.
Management offered it.
If fans want to criticize someone for that deal, the criticism belongs with Brendan Shanahan and the front office that approved it.
The more time passes, the easier it becomes to understand why Shanahan hasn't landed another job.
So where does that leave us?
I think the Leafs should explore every option.
I think Morgan Rielly has every right to control his future.
And I think Leafs fans need to stop treating every tweet like it's an official press release from the organization.
For now, I'm going to do something that seems increasingly rare in today's hockey world.
I'm going to wait.
I'm going to let John Chayka do his job.
Because if yesterday's trade with Philadelphia reminded us of anything, it's that things can change in a hurry when nobody is expecting them.
Until then, maybe we should spend less time arguing over rumours and more time accepting a simple reality:
Morgan Rielly's future will be decided by Morgan Rielly and the Toronto Maple Leafs—not by Twitter.



Comments
Post a Comment