Dark Times or Deserved Criticism?
Photo From Sportsnet
So, the Stanley Cup Final begins tonight, and yesterday Mitch Marner spoke to the media. When asked if he could elaborate on his "dark times in Toronto" comment made earlier in the playoffs, his answer was simple:
"If I get a Stanley Cup ring, I will."
Naturally, that has Leafs Nation split right down the middle. Some people are siding with Mitch, while others are siding against him.
Which side do you think I'm on?
I highly doubt anyone from Marner's entourage will see this, but I think Mitch is becoming the NHL's version of the boy who cried wolf.
Right now, people are reacting to these comments. Hell, here I am writing about them. But eventually, Mitch, people are going to get tired of hearing it. You can only cry wolf so many times before people stop caring.
You claim there were dark times in Toronto, but I have to wonder just how dark they really were.
Let's ignore the carjacking because that's terrifying for anyone, regardless of who they are.
But outside of that, Mitch, how tough was it really?
This is the franchise you grew up idolizing. When the Leafs drafted you, you called it a dream come true. You spent nearly a decade playing for the team you grew up cheering for and for a fan base that practically worshipped the ground you walked on.
In fact, if I remember correctly, you once said, "We are treated like gods here."
If that's the case, then how dark were these times?
Were the dark times people criticizing your playoff performances?
Like Game 7 against Florida when you told the bench to "wake up" despite looking like one of the least engaged players on the ice?
Or was it Game 5, a game I attended, where you threw a no-look pass into the middle of the ice that turned into a Florida breakaway goal?
If people criticized you for those moments, good.
Because it was deserved.
That's part of being a professional athlete.
Look at Auston Matthews. He gets ripped all the time. Sometimes it's fair, sometimes it's completely over the top, but you don't see him running to the media after every playoff exit complaining about how hard life is.
Meanwhile, after seemingly every postseason disappointment, there was always another story, another excuse, another finger pointed somewhere else.
Very rarely was there accountability.
Now, to be fair, I'm sure Mitch dealt with some idiots along the way.
Every fan base has them.
Give certain people a few drinks, and suddenly, they think they're the smartest person in the room.
But I have a hard time buying the narrative that Toronto was some miserable hockey prison.
I was at your return game with Vegas.
There were Marner jerseys everywhere.
Toronto jerseys.
Vegas jerseys.
Heck, I could have walked into Real Sports and bought a Golden Knights Marner jersey right inside the Leafs' own store.
That's not hatred.
That's love.
Fans loved you, Mitch.
The problem is that I don't think you realize just how much.
Did some fans boo you?
Sure.
Welcome to professional sports.
Remember all those games with John Tavares in Long Island?
The Islanders fans booed him every single chance they got.
Did Tavares spend years talking about it afterward?
No.
He played hockey.
Fans cheer.
Fans boo.
That's sports.
If criticism and booing are enough to create dark times, then you'd better win the Stanley Cup every single season in Vegas because if you don't, ownership there won't be nearly as patient.
Just ask Marc-André Fleury.
Now, before anyone accuses me of being bitter because Marner is playing for a Stanley Cup, save it.
I couldn't care less.
Marner wouldn't be the first former Leaf to win a Cup, and he won't be the last.
Phil Kessel has two.
Tyler Bozak has one.
Carl Gunnarsson has one.
Nazem Kadri has one.
The list goes on and on.
Do I want Vegas to win?
No.
I want Carolina to win because a friend and former player of mine is with the Hurricanes.
But if Vegas wins and Marner gets a ring, life will go on.
What really bothers me is the constant attempt to paint Toronto as some unbearable experience.
And Mitch isn't exactly innocent when it comes to creating drama either.
After Marner signed with Vegas, his camp seemed determined to do as many interviews as possible explaining why he left Toronto, and the fans often felt like the target.
One story that stood out came from Steve Dangle, a Maple Leafs YouTuber.
For those unfamiliar, Steve has publicly spoken about receiving messages after criticizing Marner's play in the 2021 playoff series against Montreal.
According to Steve, the messages came from a member of Marner's security team.
One of the messages he shared publicly read:
"You piece of shit. Shut the f*ck up about Marner! You know zero about the game, you little puke. You'll never get to speak to him again."
If you've never heard Steve tell the story, the clip is available on YouTube and is worth watching.
When I first heard about it, I assumed it was some random keyboard warrior trying to sound tough.
According to Steve, it wasn't.
Again, if you haven't seen the clip, go listen to it yourself and draw your own conclusions.
But whether you agree with Steve or not, it certainly doesn't help the image of someone who constantly seems bothered by criticism.
At the end of the day, Mitch, you're an incredibly talented hockey player.
Nobody can take that away from you.
But when you repeatedly talk about fans, the media, criticism, and now these mysterious "dark times," it starts to sound less like someone reflecting honestly on their experience and more like someone who still can't handle the fact that people expected more from him.
If you really want perspective, go talk to the players you grew up watching.
Talk to Mats Sundin.
Talk to Darcy Tucker.
Talk to Thomas Kaberle.
Ask them what it was like being a Maple Leaf.
They dealt with criticism.
They dealt with pressure.
They dealt with the media.
They answered the same repetitive questions year after year.
And yet, whenever they talk about Toronto, it's with appreciation because they understood something that seems to get lost in all of this.
Leafs fans care.
Sometimes too much.
Sometimes irrationally.
Sometimes loudly.
But they care.
And yes, we do treat our players like gods when they give us everything they've got.
So if criticism is what made Toronto such a dark place, then I hope Vegas wins every Stanley Cup for the rest of Mitch Marner's career.
Because if they don't, he might find out that dark times aren't exclusive to Toronto.



Well said !! Gil
ReplyDelete