Jays Comeback Wasted in Frustrating Loss to the Rays
Tonight’s loss against the Rays is one of those games that will stick with fans because it felt completely winnable. Yes, I know it’s still early in the season, and yes, the Jays are still within striking distance of a wild-card spot, but blowing a game after fighting all the way back from five runs down is frustrating. Especially when managerial decisions end up playing such a massive role in the outcome.
Give the Jays credit because, for once, the bats actually showed life. They clawed their way back into the game and had all the momentum on their side heading into extra innings. Then came another moment that will have fans questioning John Schneider yet again.
First, Schneider goes to Braydon Fisher, which honestly was fine. Fisher has actually been decent out of the bullpen lately. The first batter he faces drives a deep fly ball to the left-field wall, allowing the runner to tag from second to third. Then, with the infield pulled in, Tampa Bay delivers an RBI single to take a 6-5 lead. One run? Fine. You can live with that because the game is still right there for the taking.
But this is where things stopped making sense.
While all of this was happening, Mason Fluharty was in the bullpen warming up specifically to face Jonathan Aranda, and the matchup actually made sense. Fluharty’s ability to attack left-handed hitters is exactly why you would want him against a dangerous bat like Aranda in that situation. It was a matchup Toronto appeared to be preparing for because, on paper, it gave the Jays a better chance to escape the inning without further damage.
The Jays had one out in the 10th inning, a runner on third, and Aranda coming to the plate. This was literally the matchup Fluharty was getting ready for.
So what does Schneider do? He leaves Fisher in the game.
Aranda would hit a deep fly ball that only stayed in the park because of a ridiculous highlight-reel catch from Dalton Varsho. Great catch? Absolutely. But Tampa still added another insurance run, and that extra run ended up being massive.
Later in the inning, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. would drive in George Springer to bring Toronto back within one, but the comeback would fall short there.
And honestly, the question fans are asking tonight is pretty simple: why warm up Fluharty if you’re not going to use him? If the plan was to have him face Aranda because the matchup favoured Toronto, then put him in the game. If you trusted Fisher more, then don’t waste time getting Fluharty hot in the bullpen. The decision just didn’t make sense, and it’s exactly these kinds of moments that drive this fanbase crazy with Schneider.
Again, I’m not sitting here saying the season is over because it obviously isn’t. This team is still capable of getting hot and putting together another strong stretch. But losses like this only give more ammunition to the critics who already believe last year’s postseason run was a one-off instead of the beginning of something sustainable.
The Jays will now try to salvage the series Wednesday night with Dylan Cease taking the mound before Toronto heads into a series against the Detroit Tigers. Hopefully, they can close this series on a positive note and carry some momentum forward, because games like this are tough to swallow.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps



Comments
Post a Comment