Berube Shown the Door

 


Photo From Hockey News

The inevitable finally happened on Wednesday morning as the Toronto Maple Leafs announced they have fired head coach Craig Berube. Of course, the reaction online immediately became, “This core has now gone through three head coaches.” Let me start by saying this: if that’s your argument, then you clearly haven’t been paying attention to the Edmonton Oilers over the years.

Back when Berube was hired, I was fully on board with the move. I thought the Leafs finally brought in a coach who would hold players accountable and demand structure defensively. Early on, it looked like exactly that. I still remember him calling a timeout during a preseason game and absolutely ripping into the team after a too-many-men penalty. At the time, fans loved it because it felt like somebody was finally demanding standards.

To Berube’s credit, his defensive system worked in year one. The Leafs won a lot of tight games, and for once, fans weren’t sitting there terrified every time the team carried a one-goal lead into the third period. He coached the Leafs to 108 points and their first Atlantic Division title, so yes, credit absolutely belongs there.

But even during that season, the warning signs were already flashing.

The Leafs were outshot 57.3% of the time. That’s concerning, but manageable if you are still getting elite goaltending and timely scoring. This past season, however, the Leafs were outshot 75.6% of the time. That is not a warning sign anymore. That is a full-blown alarm bell screaming that something is fundamentally broken.

And honestly? It felt like we were watching a completely different Craig Berube this season.

The accountability coach suddenly stopped holding players accountable. Adjustments rarely happened. It became, “This is my system, deal with it.” Meanwhile, Berube had absolutely no issue throwing players under the bus publicly after games. He did it constantly, and unfortunately, far too many fans simply ate it up without forming their own opinions. Suddenly, we were right back to hearing, “Matthews needs to go,” “Trade Nylander,” or my personal favourite, “John Tavares can’t produce.”

I said it before, and I’ll say it again: Craig Berube was a snake oil salesman, and a lot of us bought into it.

Will he get another NHL job? Probably. This is the NHL after all. Coaches recycle through this league faster than people change socks. But now the focus shifts to what comes next for the Maple Leafs.

I wrote numerous times that I wanted Mark and Dale Hunter running this organization, but with Mats Sundin and John Chayka now leading the front office, that clearly is not happening.

One name that still interests me, though, is former Vegas Golden Knights coach Bruce Cassidy.

Cassidy was reportedly a target for the Oilers before Vegas denied permission for an interview. And honestly? I understand why Vegas handled it that way. There is zero chance you willingly allow a former coach to stay inside your division. Imagine Cassidy goes into Edmonton next year, wins the division, knocks Vegas out of playoff contention, or even eliminates them in a playoff series. That would make Vegas management look ridiculous for firing him in the first place.

Time will tell where the Leafs go from here, but this is the first major move under John Chayka, and I highly doubt it will be the last.

Also, can we take a second to laugh at all the TSN insiders who spent weeks insisting Berube was absolutely returning next season? That report aged about as well as a bag of milk sitting in the July sun.

And here’s something else worth remembering going forward: in July, Rogers Communications officially takes full ownership of MLSE properties. So when it comes to Leafs reports and inside information, maybe people should start paying closer attention to Rogers employees, considering they literally work for the company that owns the team.

Think about it. Nick Kypreos reported during the California road trip that the Leafs were going to fire Brad Treliving. What happened? Then both Nick and Elliotte Friedman reported that Mats Sundin and John Chayka were heading to the front office, and once again, they were right.

Maybe that isn’t a coincidence anymore.

Comments

Popular Posts