Survived the Ninth, But the Problem Remains

 


Photo From Sportsnet

Patrick Corbin took the ball for the Jays, and right from the first pitch, you could tell he had it working. Five innings, just one run, three strikeouts—but more importantly, he kept things simple. Pitch to contact, let the defence do its job. And time after time, when Toronto needed a ground ball, Corbin delivered.

Now, I’m not going to go inning-by-inning like I usually do, because honestly, there’s a bigger conversation that needs to happen here. But before we get there, credit where it’s due—the bats are starting to wake up. Vlad Guerrero Jr. pushed his hit streak to 12 games with a sixth-inning knock, Dalton Varsho chipped in with a pair of hits, and the Jays clawed their way to a 4–1 lead heading into the ninth.

And that’s where everything shifted.

We saw Jeff Hoffman the night before settle things down after a shaky start—give up a hit, sure, but then strike out three straight and lock it down. That’s what you want from your closer. That’s what you need.

Tuesday? Completely different story.

He gets the first out. Looks fine. Even gets ahead in counts. Then Mike Trout steps in and lines a single—and just like that, it all unravels. And here’s the thing: it’s Mike Trout. He’s going to get his hits. A one-out single shouldn’t derail you. It’s 90 feet. It’s not a four-run homer.

But from that moment on, Hoffman looked like a guy fighting himself more than the hitters. Two hit batters. An RBI single. Suddenly, it’s a two-run game, the bases are loaded, and the entire stadium can feel it slipping. John Schneider had seen enough and turned to Louie Varland, who needed exactly one pitch to clean up the mess with a game-ending double play.

Crisis avoided—but let’s not pretend that solves anything.

I’ve tried to defend Jeff Hoffman. I really have. But we’re 23 games into the season, and the warning signs aren’t just there—they’re blaring. Go back to Arizona: two singles, a walk, then boom—grand slam. Now this. Three saves in six chances with a 7.59 ERA? That’s not a slump. That’s a problem.

And the frustrating part? None of this is new. We saw it last year. Yes, he had 33 saves—but he also blew eight of them, second most in the American League. And here we are again, early in 2026, and he’s already tied for the MLB lead in blown saves.

At some point, it stops being “just a rough stretch.”

Watching it unfold, it feels mental. Like the moment something goes wrong, everything speeds up for him. Tuesday was the perfect example—you get the first out, you’re in control, then one base hit and it’s like the entire outing spirals.

As fans, we don’t know exactly what’s going on in his head. But it sure looks like a confidence issue.

And we’ve seen how this organization handles that before. Look at Brandon Little—he struggled, got sent down to Buffalo, and since then? Lights out. Not a single run allowed with Buffalo. Different role, sure, but the principle still applies. Reset. Rebuild. Come back better.

Because right now, Hoffman isn’t giving this team stability at the back end—and if that doesn’t change, you can forget about meaningful baseball in October.

Now, John Schneider will stand there and say he has full confidence in his guy. That’s what managers do. But baseball isn’t about words—it’s about results. And the numbers are screaming that something’s off.

What doesn’t help is the mixed messaging. When Brandon Little struggled, Schneider was quick to say, “If players can’t get it done here, we’ll find ones who will.” Fair enough. That’s accountability.

But then you have the situation with Tyler Heineman in Chicago, where Schneider reportedly tore into him to the point it brought him to tears. Again, this is the big leagues—nobody’s arguing that. But you can’t pick and choose when to be hard on players and when to shield them, like he does with Hoffman.

If you’re going to hold guys accountable, it has to be across the board. Otherwise, you lose the room. It’s that simple.

At the end of the day, this feels like a situation where a reset might be the best option. A trip down the QEW to Buffalo, some lower-pressure innings, and a chance for Hoffman to find himself again. Because the version we’re seeing right now? That’s not sustainable.

Lost in all of this, the Jays did win the series—their first since opening weekend against the Athletics. That matters. They’ll send Eric Lauer to the mound Wednesday afternoon looking for the sweep before heading home, with Thursday off and Cleveland coming into town for the weekend.

They’re still just two games out of a Wild Card spot, even with Texas and Minnesota picking up wins. And maybe that’s the silver lining here—despite all the inconsistencies, despite the bullpen scares, this team is starting to trend in the right direction.

Three straight wins. Bats are heating up. Reinforcements on the way.

Something is building here.

But if the Jays are serious about keeping it going, they’re going to need answers in the ninth inning—and soon.

Comments

Popular Posts