A Rough Night for Scherzer but Not All is Lost for the Jays

 


From Sportsnet

When the Toronto Blue Jays announced they were bringing back Max Scherzer, I had one major concern: his age.

And right now… It’s looking like that concern was justified.

Before anyone jumps in with, “What about his start in Arizona?”—yes, he was solid in that outing. No argument there. But zoom out for a second. After Friday night, Scherzer sits at 1–3 with a 9.64 ERA, and the home run ball has become a real problem. At times, it honestly looks like he’s pitching in a Home Run Derby rather than a major league game.

Friday night was supposed to feel like a reset. Back home. Weekend series. A chance to build some momentum against the Cleveland Guardians.

Instead, it unravelled almost immediately.

Scherzer lasted just three innings, threw 81 pitches, and was tagged for seven runs—five of them coming before fans could even settle into their seats in the first inning. He couldn’t find the strike zone, and when he did, Cleveland didn’t miss. It was one of those outings where every mistake felt amplified, and every inning felt longer than the last.

And just like that, the game was basically over before it ever really began.

But here’s the strange part—and you might think this sounds crazy—there were actually some positives.

The bullpen did its job. After being thrown into a tough situation early, they held Cleveland to just one run the rest of the way. That’s exactly what you want from your relievers in damage-control mode.

Then there were the bats.

Six runs.

On most nights, that’s more than enough to win a game. Fans are walking out of Rogers Centre feeling good, talking about a solid team effort. But when you dig yourself a hole that deep in the first inning, it doesn’t matter how much you fight back—it’s just too much to overcome.

Still, something is building here offensively.

Even sitting five games below .500, this doesn’t feel like a dead team. The swings look better. The at-bats feel more competitive. And maybe I’m going out on a limb, but I still believe this group is going to turn things around and start stacking wins. When they do, nights like this will be remembered as early-season bumps, not defining moments.

And help is coming—at least on the mound.

With Kevin Gausman and Dylan Cease lined up for the final two games of the series, the Jays are in a position to stabilize things quickly. That’s reliable, high-end starting pitching. If the offence keeps trending upward, there’s no reason this team can’t bounce back and take the series.

Now, shifting gears for a second—because there was another major development before first pitch.

The Jays announced that Jeff Hoffman is no longer the closer.

Instead, they’re moving to a bullpen-by-committee approach. One night it could be Varland, the next it could be Fisher. And while they still plan to use Hoffman, you can’t help but ask the obvious question:

Why?

He’s struggling. The confidence clearly isn’t there right now. And if you keep throwing him into high-leverage spots while he’s trying to figure things out, you risk making the situation worse. Sometimes the best move isn’t to push through—it’s to step back, reset, and rebuild.

That said, give Hoffman credit.

He’s handling it exactly how you’d want a player to handle it.

Shi Davidi shared his reaction, and it says everything you need to know:

“I want the Blue Jays to be in the best position to win, and if that means I’m not the sole closer, then that’s what it is right now… We’ve got plenty of guys that can do what I do. They’re doing it better than what I’m doing right now.”

That’s accountability. That’s professionalism. And honestly, that’s the kind of mindset you can build off of.

Now the focus shifts to Saturday.

Game two.

Another chance to reset the tone of the series.

And even after a night like this, I’m still saying it—I believe this team is going to turn it around.

Because if the pitching stabilizes and the bats keep trending the way they are right now, this won’t be the version of the Blue Jays we’re talking about for much longer.

Comments

Popular Posts