Three Trades No Direction Another Lost Season
Photo From Sportsnet
I didn’t write last night when the Trade Deadline ended because I wanted the dust to settle. I wanted to take a step back, look at everything the Leafs did, and really think about it.
Unfortunately, the more I thought about it, the worse it looked.
Toronto got off to what seemed like a promising start when they moved Nicolas Roy to Colorado. The Leafs were finally acting like sellers, which was the correct move for a team that has spent most of the season proving it simply isn’t good enough.
Then Friday arrived, and everything slowed to a crawl.
Why? Because Brad Treliving set the price too high on the players he wanted to move. In the final two games before the deadline, Toronto sat Bobby McMann, Scott Laughton, and Oliver Ekman-Larsson for what the team called “roster management purposes.” For those unfamiliar with front office code language, that simply means: we’re trying to trade you.
So we waited.
Three o’clock finally arrived, and we heard the Leafs had traded Bobby McMann to Seattle for a second-round pick in 2027 and a fourth-round pick in 2026.
Wait a second, Brad. I thought the asking price was a first-round pick or two seconds.
So what happened? Did reality finally tap you on the shoulder? Did you realize nobody was paying that price, and panic at the last second because you knew you had to move him?
I like Bobby McMann as a player, but his value clearly dropped this season because the production simply hasn’t been there. If the Leafs wanted a big return, the time to move him was November or December, when his value was at its peak. Instead, the Leafs waited… and waited… and waited… until the market cooled and the return shrank.
Then came the Scott Laughton trade.
Toronto sent Laughton to the Los Angeles Kings for a conditional third-round pick that becomes a second if the Kings make the playoffs. Considering Los Angeles is currently sitting three points outside the postseason, that condition feels more like a lottery ticket than an actual return.
Still, fans assumed there was more coming. Oliver Ekman-Larsson had been scratched. Surely another trade was around the corner.
Except it wasn’t.
That was it.
Three trades. Deadline over.
Now, Brad, I doubt you’ll ever read this, but I’ll give you credit for one thing: you admitted you made mistakes building this roster. It only took you about sixty games to figure out what every Leafs fan watching the team could see from October.
This roster was flawed from the start.
And yesterday, you didn’t do nearly enough to fix it.
Troy Stecher is still here, despite being a pending free agent. Are we really supposed to believe there wasn’t a single team willing to give up a late-round pick for him?
Calle Järnkrok is still here. If David Kämpf can leave Vancouver for a sixth-round pick from Washington, how is it possible that nobody would give you anything for Järnkrok?
Nick Robertson is still here, too. A player who has openly asked for a trade because he wants a real opportunity somewhere else. You mean to tell me there wasn’t a team willing to take a chance on him?
When you have expiring contracts, the rule is simple: unless you’re certain the player will re-sign, you move them for whatever asset you can get.
Leaf fans have seen this movie before. Roman Polak and Daniel Winnik practically built a tradition around it. The Leafs would sign them, trade them at the deadline for picks, and sometimes even bring them back in the summer.
That’s how rebuilding teams operate.
Apparently, that concept didn’t apply this year.
Oliver Ekman-Larsson stayed put because Toronto’s asking price was absurd. Reports suggested the Leafs wanted two first-round picks and a prospect.
Two firsts. For a 35-year-old defenseman.
Unless you’re retaining a serious salary, no team in the league is paying that price. Instead of playing him and letting his value grow, the Leafs sat him in the press box and watched the deadline pass.
Then there’s the Scott Laughton situation, which might be the most frustrating part of all.
The Leafs gave up a first-round pick and a prospect to acquire him last year. Now they’ve flipped him for a conditional third.
Why did his value collapse?
Because the coach behind the bench refused to use him properly.
Craig Berube buried Laughton in the lineup all season, killing any chance he had to showcase his value. When the time finally came to trade him, the market saw exactly what Berube had been telling everyone all year: that Laughton wasn’t worth much.
That’s how you turn a first-round investment into a conditional third.
Do you remember when I wrote about Marc Savard being fired earlier this season? I asked whether that move alone would fix anything.
Clearly, it didn’t.
Berube should have been fired in December alongside Savard, and you can throw Mike Van Ryn into that conversation as well. The coaching staff has completely lost the room, and everyone watching can see it.
Maybe if those changes had happened earlier, the season could have been salvaged.
Instead, this team has spent months drifting toward the same place the franchise lived in during the early 2010s: hockey irrelevance.
Back then, playing the Leafs was practically a scheduled win for the opponent.
It’s starting to feel like we’re heading right back there again.
To the fans still holding onto hope that this team can somehow sneak into the playoffs, I admire your optimism.
I really do.
But there are nineteen games left, and at this point, the best thing that could happen might be losing every single one of them.
If Toronto falls to 28th in the standings, they keep their first-round pick instead of sending it to Boston in the disastrous Brandon Carlo trade.
That’s where the hope is now.
Not in a playoff run. Not in a late-season surge.
Hope now lives in the draft lottery standings.
And when those nineteen games are finally over, I hope the Leafs announce a complete housecleaning. The coaching staff. The front office. All of it.
Because if the Toronto Maple Leafs ever want to become a serious organization again, the management group and the coaching staff need to share the same vision.
Right now, it doesn’t look like anyone in charge has a plan at all.
And that might be the most discouraging part of this entire season.



Comments
Post a Comment