Stop Blaming Matthews The Issue is Behind the Bench
All season long, the conversation around the Toronto Maple Leafs seems to circle back to one name: Auston Matthews. His struggles, his production, his contract. And yes, when you are the highest-paid player on the roster, expectations come with the territory. Nobody is arguing that.
But here’s the question nobody seems to want to ask.
Who on this Leafs roster is actually having a good season?
Since January 13th, when Toronto beat Colorado in overtime, the Leafs have gone 4-11-4. They’ve dropped seven straight games since the Olympic break and have been outscored by 39 goals in that stretch. That isn’t a slump. That’s a full-blown collapse.
And yet the finger keeps pointing at Matthews.
Now look, I’m fully aware that Auston hasn’t scored in 11 games. That drought is real, and nobody is pretending otherwise. But if you’ve been watching the games, you’ve also seen that the chances are still there. Matthews is still getting looks, still putting himself in scoring areas. Right now, the puck simply isn’t going in.
And when a player is still generating chances like that, the drought usually says more about timing and puck luck than effort.
What people also seem to forget is what Matthews looked like under the previous coaching staff. Under Sheldon Keefe, Matthews played 350 games and put up 257 goals and 444 points, which works out to roughly a 60-goal, 104-point pace over a full season.
Since Craig Berube took over, Matthews has 46 goals and 99 points in 93 games, which projects to about 41 goals and 88 points over 82 games.
Those are still good numbers for most players in the NHL.
But Auston Matthews isn’t most players.
When a generational goal scorer suddenly looks less dangerous, less explosive, and less productive, you have to start asking whether the issue is the player or the system he’s playing in.
And right now, the answer feels pretty obvious.
Because when the entire team is struggling, blaming one player isn’t analysis… It’s an excuse.
If the Leafs truly want to fix what’s happening in Toronto, they need to stop searching for scapegoats and start asking harder questions. Auston Matthews didn’t suddenly forget how to score goals. But systems can suffocate talent, and right now the Leafs look like a team playing with the parking brake on. Until that changes, the losses will keep piling up, the frustration will keep growing, and blaming Matthews will keep missing the real problem staring this team in the face.



Comments
Post a Comment