Accountability for Thee, Not for Me

 


Photo From Maple Leaf Hot Stove

I know I’m repeating myself, but I’m done with the Craig Berube experiment in Toronto.

All season long, this team has been outworked, outplayed, and outclassed in every area of the ice. But what finally slammed the door for me was the Leafs’ latest back-to-back.

It started Friday morning before the home game against Carolina, when Berube said to William Nylander, “I don’t know if you’re a playmaker or a goal scorer.”

Seriously?

Nylander has 24 goals, third on the team and just three behind the injured Auston Matthews. He’s also got 41 assists and 65 points, both team highs. The guy is driving offence every night, yet he’s the one getting called out? That’s a strange target when he’s clearly pulling his weight.

Then the game happens. Nylander scores the goal that pushes Toronto to overtime. Carolina takes the extra point, which surprises absolutely nobody. Afterward, Berube points the finger at Joseph Woll and says the team “needed a few saves.” Asked which ones, he answers, “The breakaway and the overtime goal.”

Let’s clear this up.

The breakaway was shorthanded. That’s not on the goalie. That’s a defensive breakdown, every single time. Morgan Rielly lost the puck in his skates and turned it over. That’s the mistake. Blaming the goalie while your top defender gets a free pass is backwards.

Then there’s the overtime winner.

Jake McCabe tried to steer the puck carrier wide, which is fine in theory, but he played it too cautiously. He gave up time and space, then ended up screening Woll on the shot that ended the game. Three-on-three overtime is man-on-man. Step up, take space away, force a bad pass or a rushed shot. Instead, the hesitation cost them.

And let’s not ignore the bigger picture. Toronto was outshot 36–26. Without Woll, they don’t even sniff overtime. Blaming him for the result is wild.

Saturday in Ottawa didn’t get better. Woll had to start again after Stolarz was hurt in warm-up. The Leafs got steamrolled 5–2 and outshot 44–14. After the game, when Cowan said “losing is deflating,” Berube dismissed it as a copout.

A copout?

Craig, you played the game. Or more accurately, you watched a lot of it. You averaged five minutes a night and made your living dropping the gloves. You were on teams that lost plenty. While you were sitting on the bench, did losing feel inspiring? Energizing? Fun?

There are eleven games left, thankfully. And when they’re done, I hope this experiment ends the same way your first Toronto stint did on January 2, 1992.

Here’s more fuel for the fire.

Last season, the Leafs were outshot in 57 percent of their games. Concerning, but manageable. This season, that number has ballooned to 74 percent. Yes, they won the division last year and reached the second round, but elite goaltending covered cracks that have now split wide open.

This system doesn’t work.

Berube’s structure gets caved in nightly, and adjustments never come. Stubborn hockey is losing hockey.

Another stat? Woll and Stolarz rank first and second in the league in shots faced per sixty minutes. That’s not bad luck. That’s a coaching fingerprint. This style only functions if your goalie performs miracles on demand.

You should be sending thank-you cards to Jordan Binnington forever. Without that run, you’re just another name on the coaching carousel.

The reputation was “defensive mastermind.” The reality is chaos.

When Berube arrived, we were promised accountability. Last season, we saw glimpses of it, and players responded. This year, it’s vanished. And when he tries to flex it now, it rings hollow. You can’t command a room you lost months ago.

So here’s the real accountability question.

When do you hold yourself responsible?

Because the moment this organization moves on is the moment the Maple Leafs can finally start scrubbing away the country club culture. Fans were sold snake oil. We bought it. And all season long, we’ve been left wiping egg off our faces.


Comments

Popular Posts