Mad Max Returns
Near the end of last week, Ben Nicholson-Smith of Sportsnet started whispering what felt inevitable: talks between Max Scherzer and the Jays were heating up. You could almost hear the stove clicking. And then this morning, the kettle screamed. It’s official. Max Scherzer is back on a one-year deal worth $3 million, with $10 million in bonuses. On paper, that’s $13 million.
Now here’s where the fan in me starts pacing the room.
Max went 5–5 last season with a 5.19 ERA. That’s not vintage Mad Max. Yes, the postseason version was sharper. Yes, the competitive fire still burns. But Father Time doesn’t care about postseason adrenaline. Max turns 42 in July. Forty-two. That’s not a knock on the legend. It’s reality. His body betrayed him more than once last year, and that was during a season where he insisted he felt the best he had in years.
That’s the part that sticks with me.
I want this to work. I want the snarl on the mound. I want the bulldog mentality in big games. I want the story to end with us saying, “They outsmarted the room.” But I can’t shake the feeling that the same physical issues are lurking around the corner, waiting for another long road trip to tap him on the shoulder. An athlete’s body keeps receipts, and eventually it cashes them.
And here’s the other question that won’t leave my brain alone: how are we comfortable handing Scherzer up to $13 million, but we wouldn’t extend Chris Bassitt? Bassitt is younger. Durable. Adaptable. He can start. He can relieve. We literally saw him do it in the playoffs. Yet somehow, that didn’t earn him the same urgency.
Maybe the front office sees something I don’t. Maybe the incentives protect the team. Maybe this becomes a bargain that looks brilliant in September.
But right now, it feels like a gamble on reputation over reliability.
Time will tell if this Scherzer contract pays off. I hope I’m wrong. I just can’t say I’m confident.



Comments
Post a Comment